A Roto tiller and mini tiller both perform the same job, but on very different scales. They will both help prepare garden beds for planting, can break up new soil, till weeds or plants under and are great for mixing in compost. However, the one you choose will depend largely on your landscaping and your needs as a gardener.
The Size Difference
A roto tiller is much larger than a mini tiller. The roto tiller is ideal for working in large, open spaces that are directly on the ground. However, these machines won’t work in most city gardens that are smaller, or in raised beds. They are not appropriate for narrow garden beds and areas that are hedged in on all sides by concrete. Mini tillers are the appropriate choice for these applications. Their smaller size allows them to be lifted into raised beds. Their slim design allows them to be used in beds that are smaller or narrower, and they can also be used in areas that are closer to concrete.
Mini tillers are perfect for working around other plants, in between established shrubs and in other small areas. They can be used alongside a house or next to a fence. Roto tillers, on the other hand, are not appropriate for these areas. The bulkier machines are great for clearing large areas but are not able to handle work in small areas and can cause damage to existing plants and structures if they get too close to them. Roto tillers may move and shift as they are being used, making them difficult for some people to operate.
For the quietest tiller, choose an electric mini tiller. If you don’t want to bother with power cords, a basic gas-powered mini tiller will also be reasonably quiet. Tillers that use a gas and oil mixture are louder, and roto tillers are also quite loud.
Rear-tined tillers use the blade wheels themselves to more the tiller. Front-tined tillers feature a set of wheels behind the blades that will help move the tiller forward. The more powerful mini-tillers are rear-tined and are the proper choice when working with heavy soil and clay. Roto tillers move forward based on the operation of the tines. The speed will be set largely by the operator and the ground that is being tilled.
Mini tillers are not as powerful as the full-size roto tillers. They are designed for small jobs and will not be able to power through large jobs, such as preparing large vegetable gardens or reseeding entire lawns.
Mini tillers cost a fraction of what roto tillers cost. Their low price makes them attractive to people who have a number of small projects to tackle. Roto tillers are more expensive because they are more powerful and much larger machines.
Mini tillers are relatively easy to use. Roto tillers, with their increased power and larger tines, can be harder to use. Most people can work a mini tiller, but a roto tiller requires a great deal of upper body strength. If the machine strikes a rock or other solid object under the ground, it can shift violently and unpredictably in any direction. Injuries can easily result if they are not used properly and with care. However, using a roto tiller will get the job done much faster than trying to use hand tools.
The choice you make between a roto tiller and a mini tiller depends largely on your needs. If you have large projects to do, or will be breaking up fresh ground away from structures then a roto tiller is probably the right option. People with many small projects to tackle, however, will probably prefer a mini tiller. This is especially true if you are working near other structures, between existing plants or with raised beds.
Photo source: dedrawolff