Gardening tips, gardening info and heaps of ideas to help gardeners of all experience get more out of their hobby and out of their gardens.
No longer will doctors be recommending that patients take time to "smell the roses" after findings of a 15-year study were published in this week's New England Journal of Medicine.
The study, conducted by chief researcher Dr Eims Fuller-Krapp of the Gray Cancer Institute, analysed more than 8000 throat cancer victims searching for clues to the disease. While cigarette smoking and environmental pollution have taken the rap by media sources over the years it now appears that smelling roses may instead be the largest contributor.
"The common thread we found in each patient was that they had all been accustomed to smelling roses over their lifetime. The more serious cases, and those that resulted in premature death, were those patients who actually tended a rose garden in their own yard. There was a direct link between the number of rose bushes a patient grew and how severe the onset was, " Dr Fuller-Krapp said.
The study had isolated a single chemical that naturally occurred in rose blooms nicknamed Chemical X. This chemical, now known as Krappsii - after the researcher who discovered it, develops within the bloom once it has been pollinated. Initially it has no potency but after a few hours degrades into its carcinogenic form.
It affects humans and animals that inhale the scent by firstly de-stabilising the immune system. Then, over many years it builds and solidifies in a person's respiratory system eventually resulting in acute forms of throat cancer. While other forms of cancer such as lung, tongue and cheek have been linked, researchers are quick to point out that Krappsii isn't the prime source of these forms.
Rose Whiffsmith, a survivor of throat cancer, was not surprised when she heard that smelling roses may have been the main contributor of her disease.
"My parents ran a rose nursery for many years and Dad's desire to achieve the greatest rose scent was his driving force until he died prematurely in 1985. Mum outlived him by another 3 years and I was diagnosed with this form of cancer in 2003. Had we known back then that smelling roses was so dangerous to our health, I'm sure my parents would have found another hobby."
Since the discovery and recent publicity surrounding the findings, authorities have been requesting the flower shows, such as Chelsea, remove their rose exhibitions and that nurseries and garden centres cease to stock these plants. Local councils have also started removing them from their public gardens.
The UK Department of Health has produced an expensive campaign aimed at informing gardeners of the danger or growing roses and encouraging growers to replace them with safer substitutes.
Source: April 1 Media
Comments
So, you're telling me I quit smoking for nothing, then? Hmmph! Interesting article, Stuart -- enjoy your day. :)
Posted by: Nancy Bond | April 1, 2009 8:50 AM
Oh my goodness, Stuart! This is something I could never have imagined! WHO could have? I mean, it just seems like science fiction:-0
Is it ALL types of roses, all varieties? This is bizaar, really. It almost seems like an April Fools joke! Think of what would happen on Valentine's Day if there are no roses~
I had Salivary Gland Cancer of the Hard & Soft Palate, and Dr's could not identify the cause. It was not related to smoking...many studies linked it to Radiation. Possibly from X-rays, Dental Procedures, and even Environmental Radiation. It was really a scary situation and I had 3 surgeries, a palate transplant and radiation. I'm fine today after 5 yrs.
I'm grateful, for sure...
But it's been an unanswered question as to why I got that. The study you mention discusses throat cancer; not tongue, cheek, lung, etc. My soft palate is directly connected to my throat! I can feel the connection with my tongue!
But, I only grow carpet roses...ground cover which blooms non stop all summer long. There's no maintenance so I'm not hovering over them...nor spending time smelling them. But I do get roses from my husband. I guess I'm going to have to tell him to stop!
I wonder if this problem could effect effect products like cologne and hand creams, etc. My favorites are Rose scented...and I use them as often as I can:-)
My Dad used to call me his 'Little Rose Bud'. Now maybe I'm looking for things that don't matter here...but it does seem like an eerie connection now, doesn't it???
Geez, I wonder what the rest of the Blotanical Garden Bloggers are going to have to say about this ROSE-CANCER Relationship???
It's horrible, is all I can say!!!
Posted by: Jan@ThanksFor2Day | April 1, 2009 9:06 AM
April Fools.....! ??
Posted by: Grace | April 1, 2009 9:20 AM
Has anyone looked into the possibly related link between this study and falling in the sh*t and coming up smelling of roses? ;)
Posted by: VP | April 1, 2009 9:23 AM
Hmmm.... I see it's already April 1st in your neck of the woods!
Posted by: Sheila | April 1, 2009 9:25 AM
I am very gullible. It's a trait I've had all my life.
Happy April Fools Day, Stuart ;-/ Geez. It's not really that funny now.
Posted by: Jan@ThanksFor2Day | April 1, 2009 9:53 AM
Dr. Fuller - Krapp and Rose Whiffsmith - excellent!
Posted by: Cory | April 1, 2009 9:53 AM
Just a note to tell you that I'm quitting Blotanical.
Posted by: Jan@ThanksFor2Day | April 1, 2009 9:59 AM
Happy April Fool's Day!
Posted by: Carol, May Dreams Gardens | April 1, 2009 12:22 PM
LOL - absolutely brilliant!
Posted by: Mr. McGregor's Daughter | April 1, 2009 11:56 PM
Stuart: APRIL FOOLS!! I'm not really quitting Blotanical;-) Jan
Posted by: Jan@ThanksFor2Day | April 2, 2009 12:31 AM
Stuart: Happy April Fools Day!! I'm not really quitting Blotanical;-)
Posted by: Jan(ThanksFor2Day) | April 2, 2009 12:38 AM
Oh, Stuart! Thanks for the laugh! Much needed on this grey April Fool's Day!
Posted by: our friend Ben | April 2, 2009 3:30 AM